To Buy or Not to Buy?
1 = horrible
2 = bad
3 = average
3.5 = good (many better beers out there; won’t buy this again)
4 = very good
4.5 = great
5 = rare best
A Note on the Style: Coffee Stout
Coffee Stout is actually not a style you find described in the BJCP (Beer Judge Certification Program). A coffee stout is essentially an American stout in which the brewer has added coffee beans or grounds to the boiling wort. The result is generally a beer of middling alcohol content (say, 5% – 7% ABV), low to middling hop bitterness (30 – 60 IBU), and a pronounced roasted coffee flavor.
Cappuccino Stout, Lagunitas Brewing Co.
Rating: 4.2 / 5
22 oz. bottle, 9.2% ABV, 82 IBU.
This is a double stout, by the way. The other two beers in this roundup are regular stouts.
A nice looking pour from a bomber into a tulip glass. Somewhat thin-looking, black, to be sure, with a smallish head, and very sticky lacing.
Perhaps this bottle hasn’t benefited from sitting in my cellar for five months. The coffee aroma seems muted. A lactose smoothness in the nose makes the coffee-and-cream character astonishingly accurate. (Pretty sure this was not brewed with any lactose, though, so technically it’s not a “sweet stout” or “milk stout.”) There’s some vanilla, biscuit, unsweetened cocoa, and a grassy bitterness that must be hops.
Coffee flavor in the mouth is highly bitter, a mouth-puckering acid disrupted some by a milky sweetness that renders the burnt flavor a semisweet chocolate. The vanilla comes forward, with lots of dark chocolate and a subtle buttery caramel. Finish dries out a bit . . . No. Scratch that. The finish is pretty dang sweet. Yes, it’s black coffee and sugar.
If not for being a bit watery in body, the lactose-seeming creaminess makes the “capuccino” element awesomely spot-on.
I used to be in love with this beer. I’m wondering, it should be noted, if five months sitting has hurt this beer. I’ll have to wait ’til next year to see if a fresh specimen recaptures that old magic.
Jingle Java, Bent River Brewing Co.
Rating: 4.55 / 5
12-oz. bottle, 6.5% ABV, 29 IBU.
How lucky to have found this winter holiday beer still lingering in the singles cooler of my neighborhood bottle shop. It’s fabulous.
This is the most stunning coffee flavor I’ve ever had in a beer. It really is an iced-Americano, with carbonation. The aroma is pure cold coffee with milk.
Flavor in the mouth is uncannily straight-up fresh-brewed iced coffee. There’s a tart, tinny hop bitterness that tries to remind one this is beer. But the aggressive French-roast flavor resists such a notion. There’s a nice sweet vanilla in the background that helps a milk chocolate undercurrent emerge from the dark depths.
Best coffee stout I’ve ever had. Blows doors on New Glarus Coffee Stout. While there are better coffee-infused stouts of imperial strength (Central Waters Brewhouse, 8.2%; Southern Tier Mokah, 10%), Jingle Java beats anything in the 6% – 7% alcohol range.
I wonder how much the low bitterness (29 IBU) plays a part in this brew’s success?
Java Lava, Pearl Street Brewing Company
Rating: 3.9 / 5
12 oz. bottle, 6.0% ABV, ? IBU
Wow, a third really good coffee stout in one night. USA! USA!
Earlier I had Jingle Java, by Bent River, out of Rock Island, Illinois. I’ve heard Bent River has an amazing imperial stout festival. The Jingle Java was actually a cut above this one, but this is still rather decent.
It’s not over the top amazing, like the Jingle Java. But this beer has an excellent demitasse essence. Great creamy mouthfeel, despite the high carbonation.
Hmm. As the level in my glass recedes, I see it’s actually nowhere near as good as the Jingle Java. But it’s a solid brew.